MsBarrows' Maunderings |
Head Stuffed Full of Useless Knowledge I'm a bibliophile, reading mainly science fiction and fantasy books, with a fairly recent manga addiction as well. When I'm not writing or gaming, I'm probably reading (including picking up a book or toggling to another window to read every time I hit a loading screen). Current gaming obsessions include LOTRO, DA:O, DA2, and Skyrim. I sometimes attempt photography. And I may be a little obsessed with the Finnish heavy metal cello band, Apocalyptica. |
I always interpreted the dialogue below (under the read more) to mean Alistair was born and living at Redcliffe Castle before Arl Eamon married Isolde. That the Guerrin wedding was put off due to King Maric’s opposition. And that once Isolde arrived at Castle Redcliffe, Alistair was treated worse and eventually Eamon sent him off to the Chantry at Isolde’s insistence.
I also believe Isolde’s continuing hatred of Alistair is clear when she meets him again with Teagan after the battle with the undean - “Alistair. What are YOU doing here?” Her tone just drips conrtempt at best.
I believe that she may not have known he was Maric’s son - Eamon may have kept that secret.
Just to provide some age check points - in the Stolen Throne after the battle of West Hill Rowan remembers her brothers Teagan , 8 and Eamon 15 - that’s in 8:99 Blessed. So it’s not unreasonable to assume Eamon met Isolde while recovering the arling sometime after Maric defeated Meghren and that they didn’t marry until the early teens, due to Maric’s opposition.
I;d appreciate any thoughts or canon which provides a different viewpoint. This, btw, has nothing to do with the “Who is Alistair’s mother discussion”. It’s just - was Alistair living at Redcliffe before Eamon married Isolde?
Game dialogue re: Alistair’s childhood:follows below:
While I think Alistair can be a very unreliable narrator at times, I’ve always accepted this dialogue at face value, since he is quite specific about the sequence of events and the cause/effect. (I also find it interesting that Connor’s birth would have come right about the time that Alistair was banished to the Chantry. *shrug*)
I have always assumed that it is no coincidence that Alistair was sent to the Chantry around the time Connor was born. And that Isolde didn’t know, or didn’t believe, the truth about Alistair’s parentage.
Agreed, it’s also been my headcanon for ages now that Alistair was already at Redcliffe for some time before Isolde and Eamon finally married. I peg part of the reason for the wedding happening so late - some years after Eamon most likely recovered Redcliffe - as being that *Rowan* opposed their marriage, so it wasn’t until after she died that Eamon finally married Isolde. After which Alistair spent several years growing up as an orphan in the stables and kennels before finally being shipped off to the chantry at age 10. And that Connor was born after Alistair left.
And I’m also of the headcanon that Eamon never told Isolde what Alistair’s true parentage was, so she’s never stopped believing that his is actually Eamon’s bastard (especially if Eamon had any kind of relationship with Goldanna’s mother before their marriage, or even was just known to sleep with his servants when the mood struck him).